888-262-4867 (GUNS)
Shop at Gun Mall
- Home
- Customer Reviews
Colt 1911 A1 CO2 pellet gun reviews - page 1
Add to Cart
Create an online reviewand share your thoughts with other customers
| The most favorable review | The most critical review | |
|---|---|---|
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
By Gunner from USA on 2008-02-16 16:56:57 Things I liked:This colt is made completely of metal which makes it feel like the real deal classic colt. It's amazing accuracy and power make for a gun that you'll be glad you bought. I love this gun!Things I would have changed:Only the safety on the butt of the gun because you have to grasp the handle pretty firmly. What others should know:Don't have too much fun! |  |
1 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
By Randal from USA on 2010-07-10 18:17:25 Things I liked:Look and feel. I use a 45 ACP 1911 and purchased this pistol because it feel simalarThings I would have changed:Include sight adjustment for elevation as the pellets strike about an inch high at 20 yards. What others should know:The grip safety transmitted a very gritty feeling when depressing it. My pistol failed to fire any more after a total of approximately 80 shots. The pistol was sent to Umarex for repair and when it was returned it still would not fire a pellet. I am preparing to return it for repair again and will reserve judgment until I get it back. Howver, at this time I am not at all satisfied either with the quality of the pistol or the quality of Umarex repairs. |
- Things I liked:Almost all medal and looks very realistic.
Things I would have changed:I would change the way the mag is.
What others should know:Fun gun for plinking - Things I liked:Great looking pistol. Heavy and exudes quality.
Things I would have changed:Correct problem with the relieable functioning of this pistol. I bought one several years ago and right out of the box it did not shoot at all. I bought another one recently thinking that by now Umarex would have resolved the problem. Not the case! I had to send this one back and I orderd a differant model of the 1911 by Tanfoglio.
What others should know:Pryamyd Air is a great company to do bussiness with. They exchanged it right away with no problem. I STRONGLY recommend Purchesing (Pyramyd Airs $10.00 for Ten Shots) option on this pistol before purchasing. Good luck. - Things I liked:This gun makes a good replica of the M1911A1
Things I would have changed:I would change the way you put the co2 in. I find it hard. I also would make a magazine that held both ammo and co2 in the handle. Also to much writting on right side of pistil
What others should know:If you are looking for a M1911A1 to hang on your wall, this could be the one for you. Very realistic looking. - Things I liked:weight and ergos of the real thing. I use mine as a training aid for beginning shooters and with IDPA courses of fire in my attic.
Things I would have changed:refine the mechanics to be a bit smoother, and either make the sights adjustable for elevation, or manufacture a gun that doesn't need elevation adjustment out to ~25 yards; mine shoots ~2 inches high at 15 yards.
What others should know:Crosman Premier 7.9gn hollow points have worked well for me in this gun's cylinder magazine. - Things I liked:Very comparable to a .45 1911 in weight, feel, and operation. I think practice will transfer (exc. mag handling and double action). Very accurate in single action. I'm happy with the rounds per CO2 cartridge.
Things I would have changed:The spring device that retains the thumb safety comes loose easily and is plastic/fragile.
What others should know:Beware of trying to use grip scales from a Government 45. It looks like they will fit, but they don't work unless you want to do pretty extensive modifications. If you want wood grips, buy the model that has them -- there's a reason it's more expensive. - Things I liked:Look and feel of the gun. Install of the CO2 is very good, same as the CP88.
Things I would have changed:Rear sight is not adjustable for height. The gun consistently shoots high and Umarex should send every buyer an upgraded sight. Also the trigger has a very long pull in single-action, which is the most accurate action. Grip safety and trigger need to be smoothed out.
What others should know:Somebody was right. There should be developed a clip feed for these automatics. Needs to be better trigger and grip safety to improve accuracy and overall performance. A lot of sticking in the mechanism. A $200 gun should shoot like one. - Things I liked:Weighs and looks like the real thing. Fairly accurate. Comes with a padded case.
Things I would have changed:Pellets get jammed in the magazine. I use the recommended wadcutters but it still jams on occasion. I have other pistols that I paid much less for and never jam. Very frustrating, considering I paid a decent amount of cash on this baby.
What others should know:When changing the magazine, you need to keep the gun perpendicular to the ground otherwise it will fall out and roll away. - Things I liked:I found the pistol which I said I didn't have and made a point to check it out this afternoon. we were like two old friends getting to gather again. Fired it about 50 times at about 21 feet, everything was o-k. The more I shoot it , the better it got.
Things I would have changed:The trigger could be a little smoother if the design would let, otherwise suits me. The pistol isn't a model 70 Nation Match, but however designed this pistol did a fine job.
What others should know:Watch out for those magazines when you open the pistol, they like to fall out and roll like hell. If you got one and know how to shoot, then you got it made like the rest of us that have one. - Things I liked:All metal except the grips. Great CO2 lever piercing system. Single and double action. 8 round clips. Good pellet velocity. Very accurate and an accurate replica of the real firearm. Fun to shoot!
Things I would have changed:Give it adjustable rear sights like the Colt 1911 Gold Cup target model which is a great firearm.
What others should know:A .22 caliber version would be nice although it appears that clip capacity would suffer. Probably only room for 6-7 rounds at .22 cal. A tough trade-off. - Things I liked:The smoothness of the trigger. Compared to the Berreta 92FS it is 100% better.
What others should know:The way you have to hold the butt tight in order to release the hammer at first takes awhile to get use to but, this actually helps to grip the gun the way you should. - Things I liked:Well made, feels like the real thing. I truly enoyed shooting mine
Things I would have changed:I tuned my trigger a bit for double action, that helped alot
What others should know:These will go up in value and as it is they hold their value very well. I made the mistake of selling mine a few days ago and I miss it already. I sold it used after many rounds in my shop for $130.00 and I shouldint have.CommentsBy nanayo from USA on 2010-09-27 0 
does it have blowback? - Things I liked:Real like feeling - sturdy metal contruction. Changing the round "magazine" is easy. Sighting picture is nice and clear.
Things I would have changed:As others have told this gun fires little high on normal air pistol ranges - elevation adjustment in rear sight would be useful. Removable grip plate has quite flimsy looking fixtures. Grip safety needs attenton - if it is not properly pressed when cocking, tje magazine would not rotate - you end up shooting empty CO2-shots..
What others should know:Use only standart pellets which are little over sized in diameter. Loose and long pellets easily jams the magazine - better buy first just one tin of pellets and test before ordering any wholesale lots.. Grip safety needs attention - if it is not properly pressed when cocking, the magazine would not rotate - you end up shooting empty CO2-shots..this is actually a eight-shot revolver! - Things I liked:Look and feel. I use a 45 ACP 1911 and purchased this pistol because it feel simalar
Things I would have changed:Include sight adjustment for elevation as the pellets strike about an inch high at 20 yards.
What others should know:The grip safety transmitted a very gritty feeling when depressing it. My pistol failed to fire any more after a total of approximately 80 shots. The pistol was sent to Umarex for repair and when it was returned it still would not fire a pellet. I am preparing to return it for repair again and will reserve judgment until I get it back. Howver, at this time I am not at all satisfied either with the quality of the pistol or the quality of Umarex repairs.CommentsBy thepaladin from USA on 2011-07-16 0 My shoots, the mag rotates etc. but it has very little power. Based on the cost I was very disappointed. I bought it based on the positive reviews I'd read, so I agree it seems there is a quality control problem.By Ron from USA on 2011-05-17 0 I like wise have experienced similar problems with my 1911 colt. I also sent mine for repairs and it came back in the same faulty condition that I sent it to them in the first place. I eventually auctioned mine off. I suspect Umarex has a quality control problem based on the wide range of reviews as well as a lackadaisical attitude toward their customers. I would CAUTION anyone buying a 1911 Colt. You will probably get a good one (statistically speaking) but if you get a bad one- GOOD LUCK - Things I liked:This is a great shootable trainer or practice pistol for those that use the "real" 1911. Overall easy to operate. Loads easy. I like the 8 round feature. Hammer is actually used instead of a fake. The double action feature is handy for rapid shots and the single action is great for accuracy. Accuracy! This pistol has it!! Although my pistol shoots high, with everyday cheapie wadcutters I get a 1 inch group with a two hand hold at 10 meters!!! Excellent pistol. I could not jam this pistol no matter how fast I pulled the trigger. Excellent fit and finish. Realistic weight and feel. Thumb safety like the original too.
Things I would have changed:I'd like to see a blow back version. C02 cartidges in my pistol are very hard to pierce. It maybe a fluke. I'm waiting to hear back from Umarex. I'd like to see an inexpensive (under $25) adjustable rear sight available for the fixed sight version. Or variable height front sight replacement blades. My gun shoots quite high at 10 meters. I'd like to see inexpensive wood grips (under $20) or even wood colored plastic. The black grips make the gun look "cheap". I'd like a little lighter spring on the grip safety. You have to grip the gun quite tight to disable it and causes your shots to string if your not careful. I'd like to see more fps. I'm getting 420-430 fps but I'd like 450 plus. I'd take less shots per C02 cartridge for more power and flatter shooting.
What others should know:If you already own a real 1911 and want inexpensive practice or always wanted a 45 but can't afford one this pellet pistol will fill the bill and your holster. A great addition to your collection. - Things I liked:This is a very well built pellet gun and is as realistic as they come. Love the single and double action. Gives realistic practice on a budget
Things I would have changed:The rear sight could use more adjustment for windage and elevation.
What others should know:This pistol is so realistic you may find a after market rear sight that will work great. - Things I liked:This colt is made completely of metal which makes it feel like the real deal classic colt. It's amazing accuracy and power make for a gun that you'll be glad you bought. I love this gun!
Things I would have changed:Only the safety on the butt of the gun because you have to grasp the handle pretty firmly.
What others should know:Don't have too much fun! - Things I liked:It has a wonderful feel, just like the real gun. The double action eliminates the long trigger pull common in most air guns.
Things I would have changed:The "trigger safety" button is used to press on the removable grip, to raise it up to make it easier to remove, in order to change the CO2 cartridge. I don't think that it's necessary, and is counter intuitive to many airgun users, who try to use it to turn the safety on. - Things I liked:I am very happy with this purchase. Just like the "real thing". It's powerful, accurate, and very solid. The pistol has never jammed on me with over 300 shots taken.
Things I would have changed:I would like to see this pistol offered in a larger pellet size.
What others should know:Be careful when loading the CO2 cartridge and replacing the grip. The 2 prongs that holds the grip in place are a little fragile. Replacing the grip back on to the pistol incorrectly can bend the prongs.CommentsBy Paul from USA on 2011-08-30 0 Christopher, now I don't take mine out in the woods and play games with it. I agree with your complaint. I leave my grip panel off, in that way nothing going to bend - Things I liked:Identical in every way to the real thing, except for the recoil and giant hole in the target. Quite powerful and obviously high quality.
Things I would have changed:I would like to see more high quality hard-hitting CO2 pistols in .20 or .22. More visible "white dot" sights.
What others should know:The trigger is a little over complex, a pin broke shortly after I began to shoot the gun, but I sent it back and it was fixed promptly...no questions asked. I also own the Beretta FS92 and Walther CP88 and am very happy with all of them. the annoying white writing on the sides of the gun(s) can be covered up with a cold-blue pen.CommentsBy Customer from USA on 2011-04-08 0 Hi Jon, If you're still out there...I have the same question as Jerry before me. Of the 3 pistols, which do you like the best for accuracy, feel and realism, etc.? Also, are these pistols really ALL metal or are the hammers and safety levers plastic?By Jerry from USA on 2010-03-09 0 Hey Jon, I am interested in all 3 of these pistols, Which one is your very favorite, most powerful, most accurate, most reliable, most fun?
| Show: | Items |
Overall rating:5 5.0
Value for money:5 5.0
Accuracy:5 5.0
See all my reviews
Things I would have changed:The slide release scratches the finish and the finish in general scuffs easily.
What others should know:This is a fun gun to own, especially now that its very hard to get .22 ammo and .45 is so expensive. Good practice gun!