The Most Bang For Your Buck Part 2

The Most Bang For Your Buck Part 2

What can $100 buy?

By Dennis Adler

All blowback action models with self contained CO2 BB magazines, but not all exactly equal in design, fit, finish, or performance, yet they all sell for $99.99.

For those of you who own and shoot centerfire pistols, the cost of a day’s ammo at the shooting range can often reach $100, and after you are done, all you have is a lot of empty brass (if you police your brass and reload to save money on ammo) and the satisfaction of honing your target shooting skills and bringing home targets that reflect your day’s efforts. What the blowback action CO2 models in this article do is duplicate that range time, and if you have a safe backyard shooting area or a basement set up with an air pistol range, you don’t even need to leave the comforts of your own home. Dedicated airgun enthusiasts know this and gain the same benefits and satisfaction from target shooting with BBs or pellets as their centerfire handgun counterparts, only at a fraction of the cost. Skills learned with air almost entirely translate to shooting range experience with centerfire and rimfire pistols, more so the latter. A good blowback action CO2 pistol can come close to firing a .22, only with somewhat less recoil and much less noise. A .22 pistol with a sound suppressor is very close to a high performance blowback action CO2 pistol in feel and noise level. Blowback action CO2 models are good for practice, especially all of the models in this article, since they duplicate the look, feel, and operation of their centerfire counterparts.

Early equals and very successful designs, the Umarex S&W M&P40 was among the very first 1:1 CO2 models that could be interchanged with actual M&P holsters, magazine pouches and law enforcement duty gear. The Sig Sauer licensed P226 S X-Five remains one of the most accurate (downrange and in design) blowback action models with realistic weight, balance, and handling. Like the M&P, it is fully field strippable, and uses a working short-recoil, locked-breech, tilting barrel design. One of the absolute must have CO2 models produced in the last five years. It is an honest bargain at under $100.

There is still no way to learn about recoil from a large caliber pistol by shooting its CO2 counterpart, and that is always a big surprise the first time you do it. For me it has always been the opposite since I started with centerfire guns and worked into air pistols, but that has also given me the experience to write about both the differences and similarities. Moreover, this article allows me to tell you through my experience which among these well-built blowback action pistols delivers the most accurate feel and handling to its cartridge-firing counterpart.

New to the scene in 2018, both the HK USP and Glock 17 are significant Umarex designs that again are 1:1 with their centerfire counterparts.

The learning curve with CO2 pistols (and I should include the better wheelguns here as well, like the Dan Wesson Model 715 and Colt Peacemaker pellet cartridge firing models) is about the same as with centerfire and rimfire guns. The better the air pistol in its overall weight, construction, operation and authenticity, the more value it gives for the dollar.

Outside of airgun enthusiast circles and those who use airguns for actual training surrogates, the majority of people think of BB guns, even pellet pistols, as toys. Perception is one reason even the blister packed, low-dollar BB pistols sold in the big box stores come marked THIS IS NOT A TOY. And Adult airguns, like the majority sold by Pyramyd Air, and every one of the CO2 models in this roundup, also bear the same warning. Even if you are strictly an airgun enthusiast, the line that separates these top blowback action models from their cartridge-firing counterparts is as thin as air.

The Glock uses a different operating system, and cannot be field stripped, but is otherwise the most advanced of the new blowback action models with a design, fit and finish that are the equal of the 9mm model. The HK comes close but surrenders its authenticity with the usual white warnings and maker’s marks, while the Glock retains its mirror like image by hiding the warnings and marks on the bottom of the triggerguard and in a subdued grey tone lettering that does not stand out but gets all the legalize covered. The Glock’s even greater advantage is significantly higher velocity that allows accuracy with BBs out to 10 meters.

Less isn’t more unless it is

The first gun to be considered as the most for the money is the object of that line; it is the Umarex Glock 17. Flat out, regardless of the packaging, the Glock 17 is as authentic in appearance as you can get for $100. Only the most trained eye could pick up the one obvious tell on the slide, the absence of a caliber marking. The safety warning and manual safety are so well placed on the Umarex Glock model that they do not intrude on the authentic look of the gun. It is both wonderful and unsettling. On face value, the G17 is everything airgun enthusiasts have been asking for, a blowback action CO2 model that looks exactly like its centerfire counterpart. As a training gun this is the optimum combination as it interchanges with centerfire model accessories.

The full authenticity of design nod has to go to the Umarex Glock 17 which delivers the cleanest, most accurate lines and best overall finish. It is almost impossible to tell the CO2 model from the Gen3 9mm pistol it is based upon.

Even the .177 caliber muzzle is so far recessed inside the surrounding 9mm barrel muzzle (and also blacked out making it even harder to see looking head on) that you can’t tell it from a 9mm Glock 17. What is unsettling is the possibility for someone mistaking the CO2 model for an actual Glock. That’s why Glock chose to leave the 9x19mm caliber stamping off the slide. This is the kind of air pistol that my A Word About Safety warning at the end of some articles is meant for. On face value the Glock 17 should be the best CO2 model for $100. And if you are satisfied with it on face value, it is. But the Umarex Glock design gives up one feature to attain an advantage over the rest of the models in this article. It uses an enclosed blowback action design (some might call it cheaper, but they would be wrong) that increases velocity by better than 50 fps average over the other blowback action models. We are talking a high of 395 fps and an average of 376 fps compared to comparable CO2 models (some costing more) that average 310 to 330 fps. We are also talking about extending effective shooting accuracy with BBs from 21 feet to 10 meters.

Above all, this is what you want in a high-performance blowback action CO2 pistol, full interchangeability with holsters (even Kydex and injection molded form fit holsters like those shown) and magazine pouches. If a CO2 model is going to be used for training no less can be expected and for under $100, less spare magazines, these three, the Glock 17, HK USP and Sig WTP, deliver the most gun for the money.

As those of you who followed my Replica Air Pistol of the Year series for 2018 know, the Glock lost out in the final comparison of features because in order to achieve its unrivaled performance, Umarex had to make a compromise, the gun cannot be field stripped. That has no bearing on its outward authenticity, handling, use of tactical lights and lasers, correctly sized CO2 BB magazines that fit centerfire mag pouches, or the gun itself, which fits all holsters for the centerfire pistol. If field stripping is a box that must be checked on your list, the Glock 17 is not the most gun for the money. As particular as I am with blowback action CO2 pistols, I am willing to give the gun a pass for everything else it brings to the game. It is only outdone by one other new pistol, which costs more than $100, the Springfield Armory XDM 4.5 which checks every box on every list but is priced out of this comparison.

What is next best?

That $100 bill can buy any of the air pistols shown, but none of them will out shoot the Glock 17 for velocity. All but one other (the VP9) are fully field strippable, and while a couple can match it for accuracy, a best 5-shots at 0.56 inches, only one air pistol in this price category can beat it, the Sig Sauer WE THE PEOPLE 1911, with a best 5-shot group measuring 0.437 inches. The Glock is tied with the HK USP and Sig Sauer P226 S X-Five for accuracy.

The gun that wowed the market when it came out opposite a matching .45 ACP Sig Sauer WE THE PEOPLE 1776 model still holds its allure for over the top design that mirrors the centerfire pistol. The most feature laden of the current models, it is most impressive that this gun can sell for $99.99.

Except for the Glock, the other guns have the telltale white lettering on their slides or frames, though the Sig WTP is the least obtrusive due to the antiqued finish on the gun. The WTP’s finish is another plus and minus situation depending upon how one feels about customized guns. The WTP is spot on for its WTP .45 ACP counterpart, but a far cry from a conventional 1911 finish. In many ways the real individual choice comes down to favorite guns. If you like Smith & Wesson, the M&P40 is a great choice and aside from the white letters, looks and handles exactly like the 9mm and .40S&W models and has the same great interchangeability with actual centerfire accessories and gear. The Swiss Arms Beretta 92FS-style pistol and Sig Sauer licensed (not Sig Sauer produced) P226 S X-Five BB model are also authentic to the centerfire models, but do not have the fit and finish of the Glock, Sig WTP and HK USP. These three are the best guns for the money, but if you are looking for one gun that stands out as having the best combination of velocity, accuracy, fit and finish, the Glock 17 is where your $100 should be invested.

All that you can want in a CO2 pistol for authentic looks and fit (save for field stripping) can be found in the Glock 17. In terms of pure performance, accuracy, and design, it is my choice as “the most gun for the money” at $100.

A word about safety

Blowback action airguns provide the look, feel and operation of their cartridge-firing counterparts and this is one reason why they have become so popular. Airguns in general all look like guns, blowback action models more so, and it is important to remember that the vast majority of people can’t tell an airgun from a cartridge gun. Never brandish an airgun in public. Always, and I can never stress this enough, always treat an airgun as you would a cartridge gun. The same manual of operation and safety should always apply.

The Airgun Experience will return in one week. Cross your fingers for something new!

8 thoughts on “The Most Bang For Your Buck Part 2

  1. While I would have preferred a Gen 5 model 19 blowback to be an exact understudy for my 9 mm , I pulled the trigger on the Gen 3 model 17. It is close enough to do what needs to be done as a trainer and fun plinker. Less than half the price of a 22 conversion unit, but it allows what can’t be done with a firearm. Draw and fire safely practice , as well as shoot at home training. It is close enough in size that it will fit my Fobus holster, as well as mag holders.Hopefully more versions will be rolled out. The next big replica should be the Sig P365 blowback . I am waiting for a 9mm version with ambi safety.Why? I will carry it mainly in a pocket holster and prefer the extra layer of safety . Interestingly the airgun version will have the same safety.


  2. Very pleased to read this article because as of today, I now own three of the guns that made your list. You may recall I just got into air guns 3-4 weeks ago and bought the Sig WTP that I instantly fell in love with. Then as (good) fate would have it; I ran across a Sig 226 X-Five listed on eBay FOR PARTS ONLY for $30 shipped. The only infomation I could get from the seller about it was that “Sorry I’m not a pistol person, just sometimes gets stuck”. But I read your reviews and figured I’d have a 50/50 chance of fixing it. And if nothing else at only $30 its a nice looking piece of hardware I could use to learn field stripping and internal operation with. But when I recieved it last week it looked brand new and as far as I can tell it functions perfectly! And I just recieved the S&W S&P 40 you recommended as being the closest practice to my real SW 9mm 2.0 compact today and man I’ve never shot at targets any better. I try to buy from Pyramid when it makes sense (due to this outstanding site) but I had a lucky winning eBay bid of just $48+$10S/H! So I’d say I’m off to a good start! But now that Tanfoglio Gold Custom will have to wait until June. I’m pretty sure….



      • I did take you recommendation and bought a Colt Peacemaker 5.5″ barrel with nickel plating and (sim) pearl handles (from PyramidAir) as that seems to be the closest to the 22 and 44 mag single-six Rugers my Dad said he used to have when much younger (He’s 83) although I’m no expert and just went off of pics mainly and since the reviews and price were great. I also found this very nice holster/belt on eBay for $35. He likes shooting my late model guns but I can’t wait to give this to him this for Fathers Day as if I had a dollar for every time he’s told us he wished he’d never sold his old guns and how he used to quick draw off his hip… I think it will make him feel like his old “cowboy” days when he worked on CO horse ranch and road and shot a lot. And yes now I’m really liking them too and there’s more versions I’d like to have. So thanks!


  3. Dennis,

    I’ve been too busy with a school year (I’m a college Professor of Film Studies) to comment for the longest time, but I’ve been faithfully reading. I’m still grading and Finals writing, but I must add something as I scramble to meet my commitments. This “Most Bang for Your Buck” series is just too good not to congratulate and offer thanks for. It is an excellent distillation of much of the best of your reporting here over time. I expect to comment at least a little more once the summer break begins, but thank you so very much for now. Your expertise with not only air guns but also the firearms they reference is invaluable. To say I appreciate it is an understatement.

    Also, yes, I second the sentiment regarding the merits of a 7 1/2 inch SAA. I have long had a 5 1/2 incher and Ace-in-the-Hole, but I am finally going to pull the trigger on a 7 1/2 inch. (I of course also have a Schofield air revolver.)

    Michael


  4. The Hlock May be the most accurate semiauto I have fired . One flyer, lie shots at end of co2. 25 feet Weaver stance. Pistol is resting in an original Glock case


Leave a Reply