Date: 26/9/2017 9:59
0

Remington 1875 CO2 Dual Ammo Replica Revolver reviews - page 1

Average Customer Review

5.0 (3 reviews)
5 star4 star3 star2 star1 star
(3 votes)
Add to Cart

In-stock

Create an online review   and share your thoughts with other customers

The most helpful favorable review

3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:

Overall rating:5.0

Value for money:5.0

Accuracy:5.0

By Don from USA on 2017-08-30 16:40:34

Things I liked: mine arrived today, disappointed with cheap packaging the gun was in, gun overall looks great, weight is good, gun finish is great, cylinder is tight, hammer cocking is smooth, trigger pull is smooth, grips are good as I have large hands, fit and feel is nice, gun shoots great with bb's didn't try pellets as of yet. I have a crosman Shiloh 1861, and this Remington is a great addition to compliment that gun, showing how far these guns have evolved.

Things I would have changed: nothing

What others should know: just be safe and shoot often

The most helpful critical review

2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:

Overall rating:5.0

Value for money:5.0

Accuracy:4.0

By Richard from USA on 2017-08-31 17:01:47

Things I liked: Before I get into my review of this classic replica I should tell you that I do not purchase replicas for their power and accuracy. I buy them because I love replicas; particularly, classic old west replicas. I own five old west replicas; 2 Colt 45 BB Peacemakers, one weathered John Wane Colt Peacemaker, a 7.5" Colt Army Peacemaker, a Schofield Revolver, and now the just added Remington 1875 model. I love them all and use them for fun shooting often. However, when I want velocity and accuracy I reach for my Dessert Eagle every time. With that said, I was excited to add that Remington to my collection and have already had loads of fun putting it through its paces on my home range. Here are my Crony results:

Things I would have changed: Pellet Testing High Velocity: 291.7 fps Low Velocity: 267.0 fps Range: 24.7 Median Velocity: 279.95 fps Mean Velocity: 281.88 fps Variance: 56.448 Standard Deviation: 7.5132 BB Testing High Velocity: 390.2 fps Low Velocity: 365.2 fps Range: 25.0 Median Velocity: 373.45 fps Mean Velocity: 373.79 fps Variance: 42.283 Standard Deviation: 6.5025

What others should know: Accuracy was reasonably good, with pellet shots going a little high and to the left. BBs tended to simply go slightly high. Both did the same consistently. Easily correctable by sighting corrections. Better velocity with BBs. I am really not interested in the advertised velocity of 450 fps, since I know that this can be achieved by carefully controlled conditions and using very light 5.0 grain pellets under ideal temperature conditions. I do not shoot under ideal conditions. I shoot under average, everyday ambient conditions in my basement range and outdoors under whatever weather conditions exist at the time. Nor do I use expensive, precision ammunitions. I use 7.4 grain wadcutter pellets and off the shelf BBs. My testing is to provide a record of the average results that I can expect. With my CO2 collection, I like to have fun and this Remington 1875 Revolver fills the bill perfectly. It is a fine replica in every way, weight, feel and balance. You'll love it.

Sort by:
  • Showitems
  • 5.0 5.0

    5.0 5.0

    4.0 4.0

    By Richard from USA on 2017-08-31
    See all my reviews
    Was this review helpful?
    4.02 ratings

    Verified Purchase

    Things I liked: Before I get into my review of this classic replica I should tell you that I do not purchase replicas for their power and accuracy. I buy them because I love replicas; particularly, classic old west replicas. I own five old west replicas; 2 Colt 45 BB Peacemakers, one weathered John Wane Colt Peacemaker, a 7.5" Colt Army Peacemaker, a Schofield Revolver, and now the just added Remington 1875 model. I love them all and use them for fun shooting often. However, when I want velocity and accuracy I reach for my Dessert Eagle every time. With that said, I was excited to add that Remington to my collection and have already had loads of fun putting it through its paces on my home range. Here are my Crony results:

    Things I would have changed: Pellet Testing High Velocity: 291.7 fps Low Velocity: 267.0 fps Range: 24.7 Median Velocity: 279.95 fps Mean Velocity: 281.88 fps Variance: 56.448 Standard Deviation: 7.5132 BB Testing High Velocity: 390.2 fps Low Velocity: 365.2 fps Range: 25.0 Median Velocity: 373.45 fps Mean Velocity: 373.79 fps Variance: 42.283 Standard Deviation: 6.5025

    What others should know: Accuracy was reasonably good, with pellet shots going a little high and to the left. BBs tended to simply go slightly high. Both did the same consistently. Easily correctable by sighting corrections. Better velocity with BBs. I am really not interested in the advertised velocity of 450 fps, since I know that this can be achieved by carefully controlled conditions and using very light 5.0 grain pellets under ideal temperature conditions. I do not shoot under ideal conditions. I shoot under average, everyday ambient conditions in my basement range and outdoors under whatever weather conditions exist at the time. Nor do I use expensive, precision ammunitions. I use 7.4 grain wadcutter pellets and off the shelf BBs. My testing is to provide a record of the average results that I can expect. With my CO2 collection, I like to have fun and this Remington 1875 Revolver fills the bill perfectly. It is a fine replica in every way, weight, feel and balance. You'll love it.

  • 5.0 5.0

    5.0 5.0

    5.0 5.0

    By Don from USA on 2017-08-30
    See all my reviews
    Was this review helpful?
    5.03 ratings

    Things I liked: mine arrived today, disappointed with cheap packaging the gun was in, gun overall looks great, weight is good, gun finish is great, cylinder is tight, hammer cocking is smooth, trigger pull is smooth, grips are good as I have large hands, fit and feel is nice, gun shoots great with bb's didn't try pellets as of yet. I have a crosman Shiloh 1861, and this Remington is a great addition to compliment that gun, showing how far these guns have evolved.

    Things I would have changed: nothing

    What others should know: just be safe and shoot often

     
  • 5.0 5.0

    5.0 5.0

    4.0 4.0

    By James from USA on 2017-08-27
    See all my reviews
    Was this review helpful?
    5.02 ratings

    Verified Purchase

    Things I liked: I am happy that this finally arrived. I am a big fan of single action six guns. I own 15 of them in everything from .22 to .45LC with a couple of percussion, too. I have owned the Duke Colt for about a year now and been quite pleased with it. I shoot it a lot. I was really anxious to get this Remington out and compare it with the Colt. My first impressions were very positive. The parts appear to be very well made. There are no rough edges. The grip panels have a nice tight fit. Nothing feels loose if you give it a good shake. Cocking the hammer is smooth with the appropriate clicks. It feels like you are holding onto a real gun. It is hard to call this one a toy like it is so easy to do with some of the plastic BB pistols out there. I have an EMF reproduction of this Remington in .45LC. I compared them side by side. The CO2 weighs 2 lbs 4.8 ozs with the cartridges. My EMF only weighs 5.4 ozs more. For comparison, the Colt is 2 lbs 2.5 ozs. I like the pellets and BBs

    Things I would have changed: The grip is big. It feels really big after picking up MY EMF. It extends over 1/4" lower at the flared base. It is fatter throughout the midsection. I'm not sure why they chose to do that, but it is a lot bigger than any six gun I own. It's much bigger than the Colt CO2, which is very close in size to my others. Although it is really noticeable, I was able to handle and shoot it well. It might be an issue for shooters with smaller hands and youth. I would have liked to see the grip in a more realistic size. I would like to see a realistic blued version with faux wood grips. I'd dream about a case-hardened frame appearance, too. I'm not a big fan of "Remington" and "1875" in big letters (on the left side of the one I received). It's kind of like tattoos on a beautiful woman. That's the only thing that makes this look like a toy. The packaging was the cheap clear plastic common with Crosman pieces. This gun is worthy of better packaging.

    What others should know: I test fired this against the Colt at 25 ft from a bag rest. The Colt put six shots in 2-1/4" around the point of aim. With BB's, the Remington grouped 5 shots in 1-1/4" (I pulled to the side on the 6th). Pellets weren't as good. I put my first six in a 3-1/2" group. I tried again and got 2-3/4". Both groups hit much lower than the point of aim. They were up to 4" low. The best shot was 1-1/2" low. I do like being able to shoot both, but I liked the initial accuracy from the BBs. All testing was with freshly installed CO2. It decocks like it should. Just hold the hammer and gently let it down while pulling the trigger and pointing it in a safe direction. All-in-all, this is a great value. It is about as good of a historical reproduction as we can expect, especially in this price class. I am quite pleased with mine. I use my Colt to pester raccoons that wander into our yard. It doesn't hurt them, but they usually decide to move on after getting six taps on the rump!

Navigation