Benjamin EB17 & EB22 - heirloom pellet pistols
by B.B. Pelletier

Made as well today as its ancestor 65 years ago, Benjamin's EB17 and EB22 are heirloom airguns.
The Benjamin EB17 and EB22 are two American pellet pistols that are as close to the guns from the 1930s and 40s as you'll find. They're powered by CO2, which is as reliable as light bulbs due to great strides made in gas technology over the last 65 years,.
Benjamin missed the boat!
The EB-series pistols were first offered in 1992, but they were related to Benjamin's earliest CO2 pistols - the models 250, 252 and 257 (you decode the calibers from the model numbers) that were sold from 1952 until 1956.
Those early gas guns used the conventional 8-gram soda siphon cartridge that was so easy to find at the time. When Crosman brought out the 12-gram powerlet in 1954, it battled for market supremacy for just a few years before pushing the smaller 8-gram cartridge from dealers' shelves. Shooters wanted the extra shots those additional four grams provided.
Stubborn resistance
But Benjamin did not manufacture its own CO2 cartridge, nor did they convert to Crosman's standard 12-gram size, so their gas guns suffered in sales. Even though they were made at least as well as Crosman gas guns, Benjamin gas pistols took a back seat to better marketing. It wasn't until Benjamin bought the Sheridan company in the late 1970s that they began thinking about the popular 12-gram size. Sheridan also didn't make gas cartridges; but, when they brought out their first gas guns in the late 1970s, the choice to use 12-gram powerlets was obvious and unavoidable. I would love to know the conversations that must have taken place on this subject at Benjamin in the late 1950s and the '60s! You can almost smell the stubborn resistance to a standard created by their fiercest competitor!
Choice of caliber - both are good!
The EB-series guns look a lot like their ancestors, and they're made from the same brass and walnut materials. The finish is a more durable paint that will last longer than the fragile "black nickel" over silver nickel of the past. Both calibers offer power and accuracy, so your choice is between two solid models. Pick the caliber you want to shoot, because that's the only real difference between the two guns.
CO2 - the guns of summer!
By now you should know that CO2 performance is highly affected by temperature. The guns do not perform well below 50 degrees F, nor do they do well when fired many times in rapid succession. That's why there are no full-auto CO2 guns without burst limits. They freeze up! But, in warm weather, these guns really come into their own. As powerful as they are, these two can handle medium-weight pellets (up to 9 grains in .177 and up to 15 grains in .22). Don't forget to buy some Crosman Pellgunoil to keep them running right for a long time.
Heirlooms
You can't call all pellet guns heirlooms, but these two pistols certainly qualify. Everyone who holds them immediately recognizes that fact. If you're in the market for a powerful, accurate pellet pistol at the right price, you've got to consider one of these!

28 Comments:
I've been considering the HB22 for a plinking/squirrel backup for my Legacy 1000. Would the HB22 with some Gamo master points be a good setup? My dad bought a 342 the year I was born, and it's still shooting strong today (after a rebuild from a 392 kit), so I kinda grew up on Benjamin pumps, which is why the HB22 is more appealing to me. Plus, I don't want to deal with carrying CO2 if I take it hiking or backpacking.
I really value your expertiese, and was wondering what you thought of my setup. I have a .177 Gamo CF-X (regular, not wood) with a BSA 2-7 x 32 scope, and I use the JWS Diana superdome pellets. It seems to be working out well, but then again I have nothing to compare it to. I would appreciate your feedback. Thanks!
sorry, i got that wrong, im the same guy as above, i shoot the RWS Diana superdome, not JWS sorry, i forgot to proof read. Thanks
BB,
thanks for the info on how to tune up my TF99 Magnum. It is shooting in the high 800s now and is on an average of apx 880 FPS. It has some serious power and I can't wait to go hunting with it. Thanks again BB,
sav300
I've noticed that all the rifles using a C02 powersource have roughly the same velocity rating despite any difference in the size of the C02 tank. Is that limitation because releaseing more gas per shot would cause the cartridges to cool faster and cause a decrease in pressure which would offset any benefit from increased gas per shot? Is there some other reason? My physics is a little rusty. Perhaps keeping the valve pen longer would be ineffective because the pellet would be out of the barrel before the gas could completely expand.
Dave
davidandjemma,
The HB22 would be a fine pistol for your purpose.
B.B.
CF-X owner,
I'd say it it works for you it's fine. I shot an FWB 124 for many years with a Lasco riflescope that wasn't made for an airgun and I did okay. Whatever works is what you want.
B.B.
Dave,
CO2 is always at the same pressure at the same temperature. a CO2 powerlet has the same pressure at 70 degrees as a railroad tanker car full of CO2.
Furthermore, if CO2 gas is compressed, the pressure does not increase. It simply turns from gas to liguid, with the remaining gas keeping the same constant pressure.
Thertefore, barrel length is primarily what determines CO2 gun velocity. The valve has a little to do with it, but barrel length is at least 80 percent of the velocity equation.
B.B.
Hi how loud is this pistol? I shoot in a small apartment with thin walls, and noise is important to me.
Quite loud ! Enough to annoy neighbours.
I shoot in a 100 foot long garden 40 feet wideand use a 6" Parker Hal silencer (V quiet)and a 2.5"
Bisley silencer (muffles loud crack).
Adapter by AGS of England (Importers of Simmons Goods)
Pick up a Daisey 717 or 722 for quiet!
I have a Benjamin CO2 gas pistol model 252 in the original box.Any idea as to it's value? Thank you, garylum@winco.net
Gary,
It all comes down to the amount of black nickle remaining on the gun and whether it works. According to the Blue Book the range for a gun like your in the box is $75-200.
B.B.
Tonight, my FIL pulled out his old Benjamin 250. (We had been shooting my late father's S&W 78G that I recently returned to working order.) Can you direct me to more info on the 250? What caliber is that? Is it worth trying to return to working order? Thanks for any insight.
Todd,
The 250 is a smoothbore BB-firing version of a pistol Benjamin also made in .177 (257) and .22 (252).
The 250 shoots regular steel BBs. Place one in the hollow tip of the bolt and close it to shoot.
Yes, your gun is worth fixing.
B.B.
I have a Benjamin 250 pistol that worked the last time I had a cylinder to power it. Do you know of a source of the smaller cylinders it takes?
You need 8-gram cartridges. Look for them is stores selling seltzer bottles.
http://www.gas-depot.com/
B.B.
I have an old Healthways Plansman that uses the 8 gram CO2. Does anyone know if the ones from gas-depot will work with it? I read that the cartridges had to have a flat top.
S.H.
S.H.,
All 8-gram cartridges should be the same. I have used the modern ones in vintage guns.
B.B.
Need help!
Which one's better:
- Benjamin EB17/EB22 or
- Crosman 2240
for fun, accurate shooting and overall satisfaction ;) Which one shoots better and which one looks better?
Please help!
Michal,
Both shoot identically well. Get the Benjamin for pride of ownership. Get the Crosman to save money.
B.B.
Many thanks for your quick response! I'll go for Benjamin .22 pistol!
Which in your opinion scope and a scope mount fits that pistol best?
rgds,
Mike
Mike,
I detest scope on pistols. But you'll have to use a Crosman intermount and a pistol scope. Pyramyd carries the BSA scope which is as cheap as they come, I think.
B.B.
i have a benji 262 rocket real nice gun can hit a flagpole from 90 feet!will the 8 gram cartridge fit in this gun?and is gas depot any good for money orders? dont own a credit card....
You'd need a spacer to use a smaller cas cartridge.
And I didn't understand the rest of the question. Is Gas Depot a business? If so I won't know because this is Pyramyd Air.
B.B.
same guy as the post above you:
you sure i need a spacer on a vintage benji 262 rocket? and also what ammo would you recommend for the benji 262 rocket? -thank you
Rocket,
You asked whether an 8-gram CO2 cartridge would fit your gun. Since you are shooting it, I assumed you knew what size cartridges it takes, and the only other size is 12-gram. To use an 8-gram cartridge in a 12-gram gun you need an adaptor.
However, older Benjamins all used 8-gram cartridges - including the 262, as I have just discovered. Why would you ask if one would fit, if you were already shooting the gun ("...can hit a flagpole from 90 feet")?
I would try Benjamin diabolo round-nosed pellets - otherwise known as Crosman Premiers in .22 caliber.
B.B.
i had a few cartridges laying around and didn't know what they were. Thank you!
Post a Comment
<< Home