Colt Peacemaker SAA Nickel Reviews

Weight, balance, feel, realistic

Put the push pin for the CO2 cartridge on the inside of the handle.

No

Look and feel. Best C02 pistol I own and I have many.

Nothing.

I have have three of these and I intend to buy one more for my youngest grandson. We have great fun passing the time together while cutting Pepsi cans to pieces with our 6 shooters. No telling how many thousands of BBs we have gone through. Stock up on BBs and C02.

just like the real thing

nothing

Fit and finish are excellent, the heft and weight are right there with its center-fire cousins, and I found the trigger pull was light and crisp. Pretty much puts your shots where you point it, with good accuracy shooting off-hand from 10-15 feet. Very well built, and great fun to shoot!

I'd love to see a 4 5/8" barrel version!

Robust construction, attention to detail, and (200 rounds later) functional reliability. Buy extra BB cartridges - you won't want to stop shooting.

all metal, good weight, realistic in operation and feel, good replica

Came well oiled and its fun to shoot, only downside is that the six shots go by too fast you dont even know what happened.

It does not need a safety, they should remove it from the design altogether.

If you are considering this vs. a semi auto bb pistol with 18+ round capacity, make sure you value reliability and style over rate of fire before buying because you will be reloading frequently with this gun.

Well made, very similar in weight and function as a centerfire peacemaker.

It's pretty good as is!

Great for practicing.

Has the look and feel of a Colt Peacemaker. Fits my holster perfectly. After cleaning out the barrel it is very accurate, groups are within a quarter at 7 yards from a rest.

The hammer down position. It looks like something the lawyers wanted.

A lot of fun! Be prepared to buy a lot of CO2 cartridges!

Bought this for my daughter for her 10 the birthday. She loves the game Red Dead Redemption 2. The gun is a perfect replica of the guns used in the game. The overall quality of the gun is amazing . And she lives loading in the bullets...gives it that real feel.

It would be nice if it firing pellets was an option and maybe a bit more power.

Great accuracy, lots of fun, lots of shots on per co2 cartridge

Easy enough to load the gun with bbs without using the bullets, but nice touch having the bullets too

Very satisfied with this purchase, fills the void of selling my single six Ruger

I love the weight and the feel of the gun, it is very close to the real thing. I like the fact that you can rapid fire just like the real one, keep the trigger pressed and rapidly cock the hammer.

The handles feel a little cheap, but I get that, And once handles get a little oily, you find yourself with a death grip.

You will definitely love shooting this gun, if you're into the western nostalgia. And you definitely will go through those six shots quickly, because it is FUUUUUUUUUUNNN to shoot. I gave it 4 stars simply because of the value, it should have an extra set of bullets for that price. And you will definitely feel that gunslinger inner call.

DO NOT GET THIS unless you want to have FUN! This is so much fun to shoot, especially if you want something you need to slow down for. I put about 80+ rds down range, 5 evenings a week for "mindfulness therapy". Weight is realistic.

Don't need a safety on a SAA pistol, but this one doesn't get in the way (it checks the box for the lawyers). Plastic grips seem strong enough now, time will tell. GREAT GUN for the $$.

Cartridges are realistic and easy to load (I put BBs in small box with magnetic base to "dip" cartridge into to load). After first couple of CO2 changes, it holds CO2 for 80+ rds. Like with every gun/firearm, READ THE MANUAL FIRST. Get extra cartridges including some for pellets which it will fire.

The look, weight and the feel of the gun is so close to the real thing. Listening to the hammer ratchet when pulled back. I really like that it uses the same bullets as the Umarex Legends lever action rifle.

The hammers resting place when not in use.

Mine shot a little high. I'm curious to get the rifled barreled pellet version to test it's accuracy.

Style and quality

Hammer rest setback position, but this would mean a total; redesign

It comes LOCKED it is not obvious and damage could occur

Well made; fit and finish. Site is easy and very accurate at 20 feet in homemade range in the garage. Waiting for our airgun range to open back up after the COVID-19 pandemic has passed. Want to test accuracy at 33 feet and beyond. Easy to load rear loader. Good feel and balance in hand. My brother so impressed he has ordered the John Wayne version.

Nothing, can't wait to show it off at the range!

I got the BB version and very accurate with good, tight grouping in the bullseye.

Everything! This gun is a real joy just to hold & look at & it's a real hoot to shoot too. Nice Job.

Maybe an extra set of shells to practice the "old" way of reloading.

If you're gonna start buying these cowboy guns you're gonna need lots of co2 cause they are just too much fun to shoot!!! Enjoy!

Everything so far. Could not be happier, this is an incredible piece of work, what a joy to shoot!!!

Well, it came as a smoothbore bb gun & that's what it is. There really is nothing to change. An extra set of shells would be nice to practice reloads just like the old cowboys did.

The bb's load in the back of the shells so you can reload without removing the shells if you want. This is a pretty dang accurate shooter, awesome can killer!!! Plenty of fun & you get upwards of 100 shots per co2 bottle! Seems there are some guns that click 4 times instead of 3 & those are the ones some people are having issues with. Soon as I took it out of the box I checked to be sure I did not get a bad one. Before you fire the first round, just dry fire a few times to be sure the cylinder lines up with the barrel & you should be ok. Buy one & have a ball !!!

? came in not working condition.

check items before they are sent out for delivery

how do I do an exchange?

It looks like the real thing and it's fun to shoot, oh, and it looks good in my western holster.

Nothing

Go out and have a good time plinking.

I have 8 BB guns, this is the best. Very accurate, looks nice, easy to keep clean. Easy to load.

Not sure if I like the built in Co2 cartridge removal tool. It puts a bit more pressure on the scales ( handle).

You do not need to remove shell casings from the gun to put the BB into them. You can if you choose to. This gun has the perfect trigger pull. I have a dozen BB guns, this has the best trigger pull. Feels like 2-1/2 lbs. to me.