Crosman Vigilante CO2 Revolver: Part 3

by Tom Gaylord
Writing as B.B. Pelletier

Vigilante
Crosman Vigilante.

Part 1
Part 2

This report covers:

  • 10 meters
  • Cylinder advance
  • The test
  • RWS Hobby
  • Crosman Premier Light
  • Air Arms Falcons
  • RWS Meisterkugeln Rifle
  • H&N Finale Match Heavy
  • JSB Exact RS
  • Discussion 1
  • Premier Light 10-shot group
  • RWS Meisterkugeln Rifle 10-shot group
  • Discussion 2
  • Summary

Today we start looking at the accuracy of the Crosman Vigilante CO2 Revolver. I have read a lot of comments about how accurate this revolver is, but many of them never seem to give any facts. They just rave. One person did say his 357 (the forerunner of the Vigilante) was more accurate than his Smith &Wesson 586, but again, no data on what that meant — how many shots, at what distance and with what pellet. It was just more accurate.

However, I looked at the customer reviews on the Pyramyd Air website. Some were vague like the ones mentioned above, but several were detailed. One guy even wrote a list of the pellets he tried. Where there was detail I found guys were getting groups around one inch or a little larger at 25 feet, so I expect to get two inches or hopefully better at 10 meters, which is just shy of 33 feet.

10 meters

This test was what precipitated the whole report on pellet traps last Friday. I dragged my trap out of the garage and was going to set it in my bedroom, where I can get 10 meters and more, shooting from the living room. After dragging the trap out I realized that I needed at least one more trap. I will keep the new trap in my office, but will use the silent trap whenever I test the discharge sound of an airgun. Now back to today’s report.

Cylinder advance

Remember that I told you the cylinder on the test gun does not advance all the way when the hammer is cocked? Reader Benji-Don commented that his Vigilante cylinder stopped a little short, too. He noticed that a small lever behind the trigger advances the cylinder the rest of the way, and I was able to confirm that today.

cylinder almost
After cocking the hammer the cylinder is almost in position. It goes up as it rotates in this image.

cylinder locked
After squeezing the trigger the cylinder advanced just a little more (rotated a little more up) and locked in position.

trigger
That lever behind the trigger blade advances the cylinder the final amount.

I pulled the trigger but didn’t let the hammer fall. Pulling the trigger is what pushes that lever to advance the cylinder the final bit. This means I don’t have to test the Vigilante both ways — with and without manually advancing the cylinder. The trigger always advances the cylinder and locks it tight in battery.

The test

I shot the revolver off a sandbag rest from 10 meters. The revolver was held in my two hands off the bag. I shot at 10-meter pistol targets and I used the open sights that come on the airgun. I wore reading glasses to see the front sight clearly and I used a 6 o’clock hold on the target.

I shot 5-shot groups so I could test more pellets. But at the end of the test I shot 10 shots each with the best two pellets. I shot single action only.

RWS Hobby

First up was the RWS Hobby wadcutter. The first shot landed at the bottom of the target paper so I adjusted the rear sight up. Shot two hit the bottom of the bull so I left the sights where they were for the rest of the test.

Five Hobbys went into 2.157-inches between centers at 10 meters. This group is a little large for my taste, so Hobbys are not a good pellet in this Vigilante.

Hobby group
The Vigilante put five RWS Hobby pellets into a 2.157-inch group at 10 meters.

Crosman Premier Light

I don’t have a very wide sample of Crosman pellets, but I do have a box of the 7.9-grain Premier Light domes. Five of them went into 1.483-inches at 10 meters and I thought that was more like it. I had imagined before this test that a good group would be closer to one inch than two.

Premier Light group
Five Premier Lights went into 1.483-inches at 10 meters.

Air Arms Falcons

Next up were five Air Arms Falcons. I hoped this light dome would do well, but with five in 2.453-inches, it didn’t.

Falcon group
Five Falcon domed pellets went into 2.453-inches at 10 meters.

RWS Meisterkugeln Rifle

I had a hunch that fatter and heavier pellets would do better. Either it was a hunch or a reader mentioned it. At any rate the next pellet to be tested was the 8.2-grain RWS Meisterkugeln Rifle wadcutter. And my hunch was right! Five pellets went into 1.828-inches at 10 meters. I know that’s not small, but I could tell just by looking at the group that the Vigilante wants to shoot them.

Meisterkugeln Rifle
Five RWS Meisterkugeln Rifle pellets made this 1.828-inch group at 10 meters.

H&N Finale Match Heavy

The next pellet I tried was the H&N Finale Match Heavy wadcutter. Five of them went into 3.186-inches at 10 meters. This is definitely not the pellet for the Vigilante revolver!

Finale Heavy group
The H&N Finale Match Heavy pellet is not for the Vigilante. Five went into 3.186-inches at 10 meters.

JSB Exact RS

The final pellet I tried in the Vigilante was the JSB Exact RS dome. They are often very accurate in lower-powered airguns, but not in the Vigilante. Five went into 2.959-inches at 10 meters.

JSB RS group
Five JSB Exact RS domes went into 2.959-inches at 10-0 meters. This is another pellet that’s not for the Vigilante.

Discussion 1

Looking at the results of the test I saw that the heavier pellets that might also fit the bore tighter seemed to shoot better. So I took the two best and shot 10-shot groups with each of them.

Premier Light 10-shot group

First I shot 10 Crosman Premier lights. They went into 2.979-inches at 10 meters. I had hoped to do better, but that was what they did.

Premier Light 10-shot group
Ten Crosman Premier Lights went into 2.979-inches at 10 meters.

RWS Meisterkugeln Rifle 10-shot group

The last pellet I shot was the RWS Meisterkugeln Rifle. I thought they did well before so I decided to give them a chance to show off. Ten of them went into 2.251-inches at 10 meters, but look at the group. Seven of the ten pellets are in 0.945-inches and I think they represent what people have been saying about the Vigilante. Not many folks shoot groups of 10 shots and not many consider all the groups they shoot — just the good ones.

Meisterkugeln Rifle 10-shot group
Ten RWS Meisterkugeln Rifle pellets went into 2.251-inches at 10 meters, but seven of them are in 0.945-inches.

Discussion 2

After seeing this last group I now wonder how much better I can do, if any, with a dot sight mounted. So before I shoot BBs in the Vigilante I plan to shoot another round of pellets with the UTG Reflex Micro dot sight mounted.

Summary

The Crosman Vigilante is the latest version of Crosman’s 357 revolver. This is my first time looking at it, but I already see why airgunners think so much of it. I have been pulling the trigger in dry-fire in an attempt to lighten the trigger pull a bit. So far, no change. But we are going to shoot this one a lot more, so we’ll see.

16 thoughts on “Crosman Vigilante CO2 Revolver: Part 3

  1. B.B.,

    Seems like a classic case of luck of the draw with revolving cylinders influencing accuracy.

    Siraniko

    PS: First image https://www.pyramydair.com/s/m/Crosman_Vigilante_CO2_Revolver/3253 (address should be omitted) After cocking the hammer the cylinder is almost in position. It goes up as it rotates in this image.
    Section RWS Meisterkugeln Rifle First paragraph: “I had a hunch that fatter and hevier (heavier) pellets would do better. Either it was a huntch (hunch) or a reader mentioned it.”


  2. BB,

    Looks like a fun one to try. Customer reviews,……… yes,.. they are generally lacking with specifics. Not everyone has a chronograph,.. but common things like group size, distance to target and pellet choice are pretty easy things for anyone to include in a quick review.

    Chris


  3. In the section of JSB Exact pellets, first sentence, “finale” should be “final.”
    I acquired a vintage 357 and something is missing that keeps the barrel locked to the frame. Does anyone know if Crosman still has parts or if the Vigilante has compatible parts? It appears to be a spring-loaded latch whose spring sprung the coop!


  4. B.B.,

    I’m with Chris. I consider these CO2 pellet revolvers to be a lot of fun to shoot at aluminum cans on a summer afternoon, but probably nothing more.

    It has been a while, but to my recollections (so no detailed records of pellets and group sizes) my Crosman 357 was never nearly as accurate as the revolvers in my collection I have always considered to be impressively accurate: S&W 586-8, Daisy Model 44 (8 inch) and my Dan Wesson (8 inch, original model with screw-together cartridges).

    Michael


  5. B.B.

    I only have the Crosman 357, not the Vigilante, but here are some of my shot test results. These were done single action, two handed grip, from a bench rest at 5.5 meters (18 feet).

    Crosman Premier Super Match: 10 shots, 1.313″; 8 of 10 shots, 0.875″
    RWS Meisterkugeln Pistol: 10 shots, 0.875″; 9 of 10 shots, 0.750″
    RWS Meisterkugeln Rifle: 10 shots, 1.000″; 9 of 10 shots, 0.625″
    RWS Hobby: 10 shots, 1.500″; 8 of 10 shots, 1.000″
    RWS R10 Match: 10 shots, 1.000″; 8 of 10 shots, 0.688″
    RWS Supermag: 10 shots, 0.938″; 8 of 10 shots, 0.750″
    JSB Match Diabolo: 10 shots, 1.063″; 9 of 10 shots, 0.875″
    H&N Sport: 10 shots, 1.250″; 8 of 10 shots, 1.000″
    H&N Match Pistol: 10 shots, 1.875″; 8 of 10 shots, 1.063″
    H&N Match Rifle: 10 shots, 1.438″; 8 of 10 shots, 1.000″
    H&N Finale Match Pistol: 10 shots, 1.000″; 8 of 10 shots, 0.875″
    H&N Finale Match Rifle: 10 shots, 1.000″; smaller group not documented; I don’t remember why not. These test results are from August 2015.

    Crosman Premium Ultra Magnum: 10 shots, 1.250″; 8 of 10 shots, 0.750″
    RWS Superdome: 10 shots, 1.250″; 8 of 10 shots, 0.750″
    Air Arms Falcon: 10 shots, 1.125″; 9 of 10 shots, 0.750″
    JSB Exact RS Diabolo: 10 shots, 1.375″; 8 of 10 shots, 0.875″
    JSB Exact Diabolo: 10 shots, 1.563″; 9 of 10 shots, 1.188″
    H&N Baracuda: 10 shots, 1.375″; 8 of 10 shots, 1.000″
    H&N Field Target Trophy: 10 shots, 1.500″; 8 of 10 shots, 1.000″

    Crosman Premium Super Point: 10 shots, 1.375″; 9 of 10 shots, 0.625″
    RWS Superpoint Extra: 10 shots, 1.000″; 8 of 10 shots, 0.625″
    H&N Spitzkugel: 10 shots, 1.188″; 9 of 10 shots, 0.750″


  6. B.B.,
    I had the previous model, the Crosman 357; I had the all-metal silver version with the 8″ brass barrel. I gave the gun to one of my grandsons who likes pistol shooting, but it is one gun I wish I still had; I figured I could always get another one, but now it appears from your testing that the accuracy of this Vigilante is in the same ball park as the old 357…pretty sweet! Thanks for another great report.
    Take care & God bless,
    dave


  7. B.B.,

    You worked hard for those “groups” I can’t pick out a reason for the size or a pattern!

    Second sentence in This Report Covers: I have read as(a) lot of comments about how accurate this revolver is, but many of them never seem to give any facts.

    Will be interesting to see if the optical dot sight helps.

    shootski


Leave a Reply