Date: 12/8/2022 20:34
0

Page 11 - Colt Peacemaker SAA Nickel Reviews

Colt Peacemaker SAA CO2 Revolver, Nickel

Average Customer Review

5.0 (238 reviews)
Add to Cart

In-stock

Create an online review   and share your thoughts with other customers

Sort by:
Filer by:
  • Previous 12 ... 101112 Next
  • 5.0 5.0

    5.0 5.0

    4.0 4.0

    Things I liked:

    what's not to like? i've wished for years for a replica saa that does not hang a co2 cyl under the bbl, umarex has accomplished this by going to a grip frame designed after the 1860 navy/army colt cap and ball rev. i set the new umarex next to my uberti saa .45 for a visual comparison and if a person did not know the difference there would be no difference. i showed the rev. to quite a few of our customers, all were suitably impressed. two that i know of also purchased this product,one being our mutual friend tom slocum, who does our air gun repairs,i also back ordered another for myself.(could not resist). our customers are gun folks,air or powder, the shop is avon gun in avon,n.y. my overall and value rating would be 5STARS. j.r.boon

    Things I would have changed:

    the only thing that i would change,this is nitpicking now, would be the front sight height. my rev. shoots a bit above the sight. each unit will probably be different. j.r.boon

  • 5.0 5.0

    5.0 5.0

    5.0 5.0

    Things I liked:

    Great looks, all metal, great finish, realistic action, long CO2 life.

    Things I would have changed:

    The hammer, it just hangs back too far for safe handling. If you try to handle/spin it like a real one, you may (will) cut your thumb on the sharp top of the hammer, that is nearly at half cock.

    What others should know:

    The grip is longer that a real one, but this is because the CO2 is housed in the grip. This makes it a little out of balance, but I could not pass this one up, as I did with the earlier ones. If you are buying this as a gun handling gun, you would be better off with a good quality blank gun than this.

  • 4.0 4.0

    5.0 5.0

    5.0 5.0

    Things I liked:

    Very authentic. I am a strong single action shooter and this is going to save a lot of money in terms of practice. I am hoping that they produce a sheriff/gunfighter version with a shorter barrel. Amazingly accurate - from a handgun rest, it shoots 1.75 inch pattern for six shots consistently. Very good instinctive hand/eye feel at short range.

    Things I would have changed:

    The fact that the hammer does not rest against the frame is a little distracting. Definitely NOT a fanning gun - the barrel bolt does not lock up firmly enough and the cylinder momentum can cause it to skip out of alignment; the hammer has to travel too far back so it will pinch your holding hand rather severely. I have only shot it at 20 feet thus far and it is still too cold outside to get consistent CO2 performance.

    What others should know:

    What kept this from being a 5-star all the way is the faulty cylinder lock up and the hammer spur length. I have access to some usable spare parts and am considering reshaping the hammer.

  • 5.0 5.0

    5.0 5.0

    4.0 4.0

    Things I liked:

    It has the sound and feel of an extremely good replica airgun. It is really well made.

    Things I would have changed:

    I would want wood handles.

    What others should know:

    This is one of the best, if not the best, replica airguns I have seen.

  • 5.0 5.0

    5.0 5.0

    5.0 5.0

    Things I liked:

    Everything

    Things I would have changed:

    Nothing

    What others should know:

    Absolutely the best replica air gun I own...and I have a lot, over 20. The one thing you need to know is that when you half cock the hammer to insert or remove the cartages do it gently or it will advance to far and the process will have to be repeated.

  • 5.0 5.0

    5.0 5.0

    5.0 5.0

    Things I liked:

    You notice I give it 5 stars in all categories. That is because I have wanted a gun like this since I was a boy. Value for the money is because there is no other one like it. (that I know of) Accuracy, now that is a matter of opinion, I do not want a six shooter to aim with, I want to point and shoot. This gun has a good balance and right out of the box I was hitting the things I pointed at, so I was extremly pleased.

    Things I would have changed:

    If I could change one thing I would change the fact that the hammer never completely seats. With it partially open it can somtimes get in the way when the shooter trys to spin the gun. Now that has nothig to do with the way it shoots but if you want to play with it like the cowboys in the movies it is important.

    What others should know:

    Items I have learned the hard way. One take a steel wool pad and clean the tip of your CO2 cartrige and put a little non detergent 30 wt. oil on the tip. These measures will lengthen the life of your end seal, and though other things can go wrong with your gun, losing your seal is a common problem, my opinion of course.

  • 5.0 5.0

    5.0 5.0

    4.0 4.0

    Things I liked:

    This is an excellent replica of the Colt SAA. The weight and balance are identical to the real weapon. The action is outspending and the accuracy of the weapon is very good up to about 10 yards. Superb Handgun !! Incredible amount of fun.

    Things I would have changed:

    Absolutely nothing.

    What others should know:

    This gun looks much better in person than the stock photo shows. You can't help but be impressed with the detail that the manufacturer went through with this. Buy extra cartridges for this and bring out the Cowboy in you. This weapon fits perfectly in any holster made for the Colt SAA.

  • 1.0 1.0

    1.0 1.0

    2.0 2.0

    Things I liked:

    It's a Peacemaker ! And the price is right. Any 1873 holster will work and look Western.

    Things I would have changed:

    The trigger, half cock mechanism could be smoother, but it's not bad, just not very realistic.

    What others should know:

    Being the shells are loaded individually, pellets can also be fired in it. And get lots of shells! It's a drag to have to reload them every few shots so get enough that you can have FUN !

  • 5.0 5.0

    4.0 4.0

    5.0 5.0

    Things I liked:

    Everything. I ordered both nickel and blued pistols. I was very pleased with my purchase. A long back order wait but I finally received them. I have a real 1901 colt 44 six shooter and realism is nice.

    Things I would have changed:

    Nothing about these pistols. I wish the manufactures would start coming out with a .22 cal. revolver or a .22 cal. semi auto replica pistol. I am bb gunned out.

    What others should know:

    Nothing.

  • 5.0 5.0

    4.0 4.0

    5.0 5.0

    Things I liked:

    Finally after a long back order wait I received my pistols. Very nice look and feel. I have a real 1901 colt 44 six shooter and the realism is nice

    Things I would have changed:

    Nothing about these pistols. But I hope the manufactures come out with more pellet pistols. Like a .22 cal. semi auto replica. I am bb gunned out.

    What others should know:

    Nothing.

  • 5.0 5.0

    5.0 5.0

    4.0 4.0

    Things I liked:

    The fact that it feels like a real Colt,nice weight and the cylinder spins so smooth. Hammer pulls like the real thing,nice light trigger too. Bluing is just perfect! Love how it loads. Pretty accurate for a bb revolver.lots of shots on co2!!!

    Things I would have changed:

    Plastic grips but anything else would have jacked up the price. The little tab at the top of the grip seems like it may wear or break after taking it on and off after a while,we shall see.

    What others should know:

    Great gun,if you ever were going to buy a Colt,buy this one. Just a really nice gun to own.

  • 5.0 5.0

    5.0 5.0

    5.0 5.0

    Things I liked:

    The built quality, the finish of the gun and the trigger pull is fantastic!

    Things I would have changed:

    the safety is very stiff

  • 5.0 5.0

    5.0 5.0

    5.0 5.0

    Things I liked:

    Everything!Love even just holding this replica while watching old John Wayne movies!

    Things I would have changed:

    Offer other barrel lengths

    What others should know:

    The Duke would love it.Get yourself at least one

  • 5.0 5.0

    5.0 5.0

    5.0 5.0

    Things I liked:

    I have been waiting over thirty years for this to happen.It was well worth it. I order six. And I love them all.Long live the yester years.THE LONE RANGER RIDES AGAIN.

    Things I would have changed:

    NOT A THING

    What others should know:

    YOU.will be sorry for not buying more

  • 5.0 5.0

    5.0 5.0

    5.0 5.0

    Things I liked:

    Gun looks and feels just like the original. Finish is outstanding, it looks just like a case hardened pistol frame. The grips are plastic but look just like ivory and are comfortable to hold just like the original. Power is good around 400 fps. wich is more than sufficient for knocking over beverage cans. Accuracy is very good for a bb pistol. You can easily hit cans at 30 feet. If you are a collector of old firearms this is a must for your collection. You won't be sorry you bought this one.

    Things I would have changed:

    Maybe lose the front of trigger safety, it's a good feature but it does kind of take away from the originality and is not really necessary with the half cock safety of the gun's original action which works fine.

    What others should know:

    This is a beautiful piece, well made and exactly like the original in appearance. If you are a collector you need this gun for your collection. Get the tooled holster as well as it compliments the gun perfectly. Try one you won't regret it. Ken wilson

  • 5.0 5.0

    5.0 5.0

    5.0 5.0

    Things I liked:

    received mine 21 march. it was my birthday present (70) I have been waiting for one of this quality since childhood. the quality and detail are suburb. mine is the blued version and the finish is great. the trigger is light and just the way I like it. 230 bb's have been put down range (65 degree basement) using two co2 capsules. it has held air over two nights, no leaks. it will most likely hold air longer but is not recommended by the manufacture. I ordered 24 extra cartridges at the same time as the gun. they did not arrive yet. hope they come soon. Avanti bb's worked best for me.

    Things I would have changed:

    NOTHING

    What others should know:

    six cartridges are not enough. you will want to buy more. I am looking forward to buying a couple more of different barrel lengths (4 3/4" and 7 1/2") if they become available. I am headed to the basement range to shoot it some more. bye

  • 5.0 5.0

    5.0 5.0

    5.0 5.0

    Things I liked:

    Things I like: This Peacemaker replica :-) This is an accurate replica in looks, feel, and operation. Balance is superb. Shells load and eject just like the real thing. Loading is fun. The finish is excellent and adds to the enjoyment of just looking at this replica. Shooting is also fun and the accuracy is impressive. C)2 loading is easy and efficient in the handle of the pistol and keeps the balance right. Accuracy depends on careful use of the sights, since there is no read sight. The front sight is a needle and keeping it in the rear groove consistently determines how accurate your shot will be (along with a steady hand). Fun to use, handle and just to look at. I plan on buying a few more in the future, just because I love the look and feel and enjoy shooting it so much. It reminds me of my old Ruger Blackhawk 41 magnum. You will love it. I plan on buying a matching chrome version, just to have a pair of them. Just looking at one is a pleasure in itself.

    Things I would have changed:

    I can't think of a single thing that I would change in this product. If I was to change anything, I think I would have the C02 chamber redesigned to replicate the Colt Python, but it is just fine as it is.

    What others should know:

    This is a heavy pistol. If you are looking to become a fast-draw artist it will take some practice. This is not a flyweight pistol and quick-draw and fanning is not as easy as they make it look in the western movies. But it is sure fun to try to develop some proficiency in these areas. It's part of the mystic. This is your gun if you want an accurate replica of the classic six-shooter of the old west.

  • 5.0 5.0

    5.0 5.0

    4.0 4.0

    Things I liked:

    The pictures on the web do not do this pistol justice. It's beautiful! It feels just like my real SAA, which was chambered in .357, and it shoots very accurately for a smooth bore pistol. I have been waiting for this pistol for a very, very long time. This was certainly worth the wait. I'm looking forward to buying more shells for it, as well as a new holster, (if I can't find my old one that is.) It is so great to have a single action six in my collection again. I probably won't try fanning this pistol, as that's what broke my real one. (That's what I get for letting my younger brother try it. Won't do that again.)

    Things I would have changed:

    I would offer wood grips stock, and enough shells to do at least one reload without having to stop and break out the bb's. Other than that, it's great right out of the box. Absolutely LOVE this pistol!

    What others should know:

    The shells measure out closer to .357 than .45, but since my old SAA was chambered in .357, it feels very familiar to me. If you like the old Single Action Army, you can't afford to pass up this pistol. I can easily see me purchasing another copy, just to have a matched set.

  • 5.0 5.0

    5.0 5.0

    4.0 4.0

    Things I liked:

    The overall realism put into the development of this firearm clone.

    Things I would have changed:

    Nothing other then different barrel lengths and grip types, however I have heard that these will be made available sometime in the future so this is not really a con.

    What others should know:

    Mine leaks, I haven't had a chance to get out and try to test some things with it yet, but when the weather clears up I will. Tom Gaylord gave me a few pointers on how to stop the leak so I will give them a shot.

  • 5.0 5.0

    5.0 5.0

    5.0 5.0

    Things I liked:

    it took 60 days to get one,but WOW like everybody else I think this one is the best,beautiful finish and very realistic down to the color of the plastic grips(can't get ivory these days)The Colt Peacemaker remind me of the stallion cap gun I had when I was a kid back in the 50s,the one using round cap in the shell.I'm very pleased with this gun it will go great on my wall with my tanfoglio witness 1911 and luger P08 for my collection

    Things I would have changed:

    nothing,I have order extra shells and cool black holster(I'll look like Johnnie Ringo in Tombstorm)

    What others should know:

    maybe P/A can add the Buntline Special like the one on the old tv series Wyatt Earp I have not shot my gun yet to check the accuracy,but like I have said in pass rewiews I'm not looking for a target pistol,but a real looking replica beside I have a Steel-Storm which can shoot 300 rounds a minute!!!if I need a target gun

  • Previous 12 ... 101112 Next

Buy with confidence

Get FREE shipping on qualifying orders! Any order $150+ with a shipping address in the contiguous US will receive the option for free ground shipping on items sold & shipped by Pyramyd Air during checkout. Certain restrictions apply.

Free shipping may not be combined with a coupon unless stated otherwise.

View Shipping Info

Text JOIN to 91256 and get $10 Off Your Next $50+ Order.

* By providing your number above, you agree to receive recurring autodialed marketing text msgs (e.g. cart reminders) to the mobile number used at opt-in from Pyramyd Air on 91256. Reply with birthday MM/DD/YYYY to verify legal age of 18+ in order to receive texts. Consent is not a condition of purchase. Msg frequency may vary. Msg & data rates may apply. Reply HELP for help and STOP to cancel. See Terms and Conditions & Privacy Policy.