Page 8 - Colt Peacemaker SAA Nickel Reviews

I Love this Gun!! I love the way this Gun looks and Feels And it has a real nice Nickle finish. I waited a long time to get this Gun because it was Back Ordered when I finely received it, it leaked CO2! I had too send it back and it is Back Ordered again I don't know how long it will take this time. This is the Third Gun I Ordered, no trouble with the other Two.

The the thing I would change is the the Hammer does not seat all the way down.

This Gun Shoots Real nice and is pretty accurate.

Everything, The finish,feel,balance and action all way above very good.

Nothing

This looks so authentic that here in Canada I have to be very careful where I use this, I might not have time to explain.

Well, I'm going to try to give a review on my new gun. First off, the finish on this gun looks like it was blued. The finish on it is like a Ruger Super Black hawk .44 mag. When you pick it up, you know that you do not have a plastic gunk gun in your hand. The lock time on the cylinder is excellent. When you pull the hammer back the cylinder rotates and as it does the forcing cone moves out of the way and then drops back into the front of the cylinder. And this is as the bolt pops up into place. Locks up tight. You could not ask for a better trigger on this gun. It is smooth as silk. The sights are just like the real gun, what sights? They are a little hard to see, but I was shooting in my garage. Outside would be better.The only thing I noticed was, the cartridges had a slight burr in the end where the BB comes out. I'm planing to shoot pellets out of this, so I removed the burr.

Remove the warning off the right side of the barrel, the gun would look a lot better. Offer the original looking Colts grips.

I'm going to keep an eye out for another PA special and buy the nickle one also. Oh, by the way, I'm getting 90 shots out of a Lealand CO2 cart. Air temp was about 67 degrees. Yes, I would highly recommend this gun to people that like BB guns and want a replica of a Colt SAA.

The styling, feel in my hand, accuracy are all outstanding. The workmanship is very good and I really like the safety.

It doesn't hold the CO2 very long. If I am lucky, it will stay in the gun for two days at most. Other CO2 guns that I have like the P38 and the P08 lugar hold gas forever.

Just shoot up the gas in each cartridge. It is a really fun gun to own.

Umarex has a real winner here. Very realistic in every way. The nickel finish is perfect and the way it functions in every aspect is true to the real steel. I highly recommend this to any fan of the single action pistols.

The only thing I would have changed on this pistol is the fact that the trigger does not seat all the way down. I do not understand why Umarex made it like that, but it always looks like the trigger is in the half cock position. I also think they could have done a better job on the shells for it. Instead of making them like the Dan Wesson shells or any number of other shells on the market with plastic tips to load, they made these a solid brass shell that is loaded in the rear of the shell. I guess I should also comment on the accuracy of this gun too. I found this gun not to be that accurate. Of course that could be me or maybe the BB's that I was using. I have not tested it much and can not give a good comment on accuracy at this point. So do not judge the accuracy by what I have to say. I am more of a collector than a shooter.

Overall I love the gun. It is not for everyone by no means though. If you do not like single action guns you will not like this gun at all. It is a true single action gun in every detail. I am a replica collector and the detailing of this gun is fantastic. I bought the silver Colt medallions for mine and placed them into the grips to add to the realism factor. I also ordered real dummy rounds to place in the gun and gun belt for display purposes which is mounted on my wall display with my Umarex Walther Wells Fargo Gold Edition lever action rifle. They look great together and have gotten me many great comments. My hat is off to Umarex and the great products they make. I only hope they bring this gun out in a pellet version as that would be one awesome gun and a definite must have for me.

so freaking realistic i love almost everything about it. Best replica airsoft gun ever made. Gun is actually mostly metal unlike other brand SAA that use full ABS plastic.

the safety switch is unnecessary. wooden grips would be better. hammer should be redesigned to be flush with the body.

buy extra cartridges, like everyone else already said to do. More bullets, more fun.

The most authentic reproduction of a Colt SAA Peacemaker co2 BB or Pellet pistol I have ever seen. Like ever thing about the gun.

Probably nothing.

Price is right, anyone would be proud to own this one.

This gun is pristine, it's a beautiful gun & very accurate. Hard to believe 127$ out the door.

Nothing

Best way to enjoy your back yard target shooting.

I just received this about an hour ago. I also bought the holster and belt. OMG I'm 65, walked up to my wife and said Howdy Ms. Kitty. She thinks I have totally regressed. Personally I feel more like Matt Dillon. This Colt Peacemaker is simply way too cool. I once held an actual .22 cal. Colt Peacemaker in a gun shop and this absolutely has the look and feel of the real McCoy. I gave it 4 stars for accuracy only because it's a BB gun with 5" of smooth bore. But at 15 feet it is consistent enough to go 6 for 6 against an aluminum can. Buy one of these and relive your childhood.

Possibly offer upgrade options for the grip.

I am predicting this will need to be wiped oiled regularly as with any other firearm. Buy 2 and keep 1 an a climate controlled safe. These may become collectible.

very well made good metal no pot metal. do wish seals were strong enough to use pellets. but as you advised I won,t use the pellets

rear sight could be wider.all else is great

great for practiseing fast draw in 1958 using daisy b.b pistol I drew in .4 seconds now it takes that long to reach pistol. so much for old age.

so realistic, couldn't believe the cost for such a beautiful made weapon, had to order another.

not a thing

please don't hesitate on buying this product, you'll not be disappointed. the workmanship quality is excellent

I originally ordered this pistol for target practice. I was so impressed with the quality of workmanship, fit and function, that I ordered a blued version also. These pistols are a real pleasure to shoot and I have received many compliments on them. Order one or both of them, you won't be disappointed.

I would like to see these available with wood grips also, or offer optional wood grips that could be purchased to retrofit existing pistols.

The Warning notice on the right side of the barrel on the blued version is quite noticeable and possibly could have been done with a darker color. Other than that, I have no complaints.

Finish, balance, trigger pull, compatibility with existing holsters. Point of aim coincides PERFECTLY with point of impact!!!!

Shorter barrel, birds head grip.

Balance sits at the front of the trigger guard. Drops right into my SA leather. The action functions as a traditional SA. Fake shells weigh about the same as a live .357 round. They fit snugly in .38 shell loops. They are loaded and unloaded in the same manner as many single actions- half cock, lift gate, rotate cylinder. Trigger breaks on mine around 2.5 lbs. It creeps a bit but is still a fine trigger. POI is dead on with POA at 10 yards. Ive tried Avanti Match, Daisy and Crossman BBs. It groups them about the same. Mine groups around 1.5-2" at 10 yards, from a rest. 3-4 shot groupings easily fall within an inch, but flyers are common. I get about 100-110 shots per 12 gram CO2 cartridge at 55 F. The finish on it is great for an airgun. The grips are the biggest shortcoming-thin, slick plastic. Its action is smoother than a lower end SA like Heritage. Its no Ruger/Cimaron/Uberti, but far better than I expected. Its faster and cleaner to reload than wax/primer loads for you quick draw folks. Its great for teaching young/new shooters. After around 1000 shots fired, the action seems as tight as the day it came. The grip panel that hides the CO2 has loosened a hair.

I have been looking for a SAA replica for years, and this is everything I could ask for!

Assorted barrel length would be nice.

Man oh man, like they say on the TV reality series Wicked Tuna: "This one's definitely a keeper!" I'm really glad Umarex got the license to produce this replica. It is fantastic! Right out of the box, the revolver was dead on at 20 feet. I got over 60 shots from one C02 cartridge. It is enjoyable and just plain fun to get such tight shot groups the very first time you shoot a new revolver. One of the many things I like about this revolver is its heft and overall fit and finish. The sound it makes when you cock the hammer is awesome. Its a single action six shooter and I absolutely enjoy loading the "rounds" (cartridges) into the cylinder. I am more than satisfied with this purchase and I'm looking forward to purchasing a holster, some more cartridges and, who knows? maybe another Colt Peacemaker SAA CO2 Revolver in another finish. Note to Pyramyd Air: please offer the revolver in the Antique finish. I'll be waiting to order one as soon as it becomes available. Thank you Pyramyd Air.

There are two things I would change on the Colt Peacemaker SAA if given the chance. First, engineer a way so as the hammer could rest fully seated and not 1/4 cocked. Second, design the trigger a bit wider. Its too thin. Other than those two points, I have only praise for the Peacemaker.

I highly recommend the Colt Peacemaker SAA for all airgun hobbyists that are interested in a single action revolver replica. You will not be disappointed. Its well made, accurate and an outstanding value for the money. I recommend you purchase a good case to store this airgun in if you decide to purchase it.

The realism, I think Marshal Dillon and Sam Colt would agree. I bought 2 blue and 2 nickel, waiting for the U.S. Marshal version to appear so I can have 2 of each, one to shoot and one to show. Whats next?

Only small details that cant be helped.

Nice all around gun.

The weight, size, and excellent detail, the 3 screws on the lower left frame above the trigger guard, the off center wire trigger, and the loading gate, the bullets to hold the BB's.along with the operation...it looks just like an l873 COLT SA Artillery Model. It give me a lot of practice for minimal cost,and it looks like Doc Holidays sunday gun. Really helps my score when shooting one of my powder cartridge SA's.

Nothing I can think of.

Order an extra 6 pack of bullets or two when you order the gun and make sure you have plenty of CO2 Cartridges you will be doing a lot of shooting with this gun....

Quality and feel of the gun.

Wish they would offer the option of wooden grips. I also tried to purchase extra seals from Umarex, just in case I need them, and was told they are not available. Not good.

I have both the blued and the nickel versions. For some reason, I get way more shots per cylinder in the blued version. My nickel version seem sot shoot harder, so I'm thinking that it disperses more air per shot. I have checked for leakage on the seal, and there is none.

The gun feels really nice. A little light from the real gun, but it works good for practice shooting.

I would like to see more power with the gun with a slight recoil.

Watch your loads, sometimes you might have a shoot that will or is difficult to discharge.

Beautiful in form and function. Over 100 shots from a 12 gram Co2 cartridge. Love the weight. Safer for learning to quick draw than your real pistol.

Not a thing. very pleased with this product.

If you know how to hold one of these 'saw handled' revolvers, this one is pretty accurate out to 20' or so. Loads of fun for plinking.